Property tax appeal help compared: do it yourself, flat-fee kits, contingency firms and attorneys
There are four kinds of property tax appeal help: doing it yourself for free, a flat-fee evidence kit ($49 at AssessMyHouse or AppealDesk), a contingency service such as Ownwell (25% of the savings), or an attorney (usually 25–50% of first-year savings). At a 25% fee, a flat $49 kit costs less once your first-year saving is above $196.
| Option | Price | Who files | Where | What you get |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Appeal on your own | $0 (plus any county filing fee) | You | Anywhere | You gather the evidence yourself |
| AssessMyHouse kit | $49 once | You, with our step-by-step guide | 3 NJ counties, Cook County, 6 Texas counties | Free three-signal check before you pay; evidence, filled-in submission and a filing checklist |
| AppealDesk | $49 flat | You | All 50 states | Evidence packet, cover letter and filing guide; publishes a refund when the data can't support a case |
| Ownwell | 25% of savings (TX, IL, WA, NY) | Ownwell | Selected states | Full service: files and attends hearings; no savings, no fee |
| Attorneys and consultants | Usually 25–50% of first-year savings | The firm | Local | Representation at hearings and in tax court |
Prices as each company publishes them, checked November 2026. We sell one of these options; the sources are linked below so you can check them.
Compare by state
- New Jersey appeal options: Freeze Act, attorney fees, county filing fees
- Cook County appeal options: Assessor and Board of Review, firm fees
- Texas protest options: Ownwell, O'Connor, Five Stone and flat-fee kits
Short version of what sets us apart: why AssessMyHouse.
Compare by company
- AssessMyHouse vs AppealDesk (both $49)
- AssessMyHouse vs Ownwell (flat fee vs 25%)
- Flat fee vs contingency: the break-even math
How to choose in one minute
- Will you spend 15 minutes filing and, if needed, attend a short hearing? Do it yourself or use a flat-fee kit, and keep the whole saving.
- Not sure there's a case? Run a free check first. If the evidence isn't there, nobody should charge you.
- Won't file yourself, or the home is unusual? A contingency firm or attorney. Ask what percentage, on which years' savings, and how to cancel automatic renewal.
The free check shows three clear signals for your own home from the public record: how strong the case is, how much is at stake, and what the evidence looks like.
Questions
Which is cheapest?
Appealing on your own costs nothing but your time. Between paid options, a flat $49 kit costs less than a 25% contingency fee once the first-year saving is above $196, and less than a 40% fee above $123.
When is a contingency firm worth it?
When you won't file or attend a hearing yourself, the home is unusual or very valuable, or the case is likely to go to tax court. You pay nothing if they don't win.
Do I need a lawyer to appeal?
Not for an owner-occupied home in New Jersey, Cook County or Texas: homeowners file and present their own cases every year. In New Jersey, businesses, LLCs and trusts must be represented by an attorney.
Sources
- AppealDesk press page: $49 flat, all 50 states
- AppealDesk company description: refund when the data can't support a case
- Ownwell fees by state (Money Crashers review)
- Ownwell advertisement, April 2026: 25% of savings, $744 average client saving in 2025
- New Jersey appeal guide: attorneys typically 25–50% of first-year savings; Freeze Act protection
- Example Cook County attorney engagement letter: 30% of first-year tax savings
Checked November 2026.
Last updated November 21, 2026. Data: each company's published prices and the public sources linked on this page.
