How the New Jersey check works
Our New Jersey check estimates your home's market value on October 1, 2026 from recent usable sales of similar homes, divides your 2027 assessment by it, and applies the test the county board will: market value itself in towns that assess at market value for the year, your town's Chapter 123 limits everywhere else. Back-tested on 22,440 real sales, the estimate's typical miss is about 12%, so a case is only called strong when, given that margin of error, homes like yours were usually over the line.
Data
- The tax list (MOD-IV): every parcel's assessment, property class and characteristics, from the state's latest public statewide file (a few years old). That's why the check asks for the 2027 assessment on your postcard.
- The state sales file (SR1A): recorded deed sales. We use only sales the state marks usable (arm's-length), the same sales the state uses to set each town's ratio.
- Chapter 123 ratios: each town's 2027 average ratio and common level range, published by the Division of Taxation. Ratios above 100% count as 100%, and upper limits are capped at 100%.
- Which towns assess at market value: from the county boards of taxation each season (Monmouth's appeal handbook; Burlington and Gloucester reassessment notices).
- What you tell us: your 2027 postcard assessment, living space if the record lacks it, and optionally your purchase price or appraisal.
We cover residential homes (class 2) in all 21 New Jersey counties.
Step 1: estimate your market value
We take recent usable sales of homes like yours, nearby and comparable in size, lot and age, preferring your own town and looking wider only when your town has too few. Each is adjusted to your home and brought to the valuation date, and the median gives your estimated market value on October 1, 2026.
Step 2: the board's test
Your assessment ÷ estimated market value is your ratio. In towns assessed at market value for 2027 (revaluation, reassessment, or the annual reassessments most Monmouth towns do), Chapter 123 doesn't apply: a ratio above 100% means the board can lower your assessment to market value, and a ratio well below it means the town could ask for an increase. Everywhere else, if your ratio is above your town's upper limit, the board can lower your assessment to market value × your town's average ratio. Inside the range, it can't change it. Below the lower limit, the town could ask for an increase. The check warns you in either case.
Step 3: the three signals
- Case strength combines how far above the limit your ratio is with how accurate the estimate has been on real sales. Strong means homes with numbers like yours were usually over the line (market value, or the upper limit); mixed means it's closer; weak means you're likely not over it, or so far under that an appeal could raise your assessment.
- The evidence reflects how well sales support the estimate: plenty of similar sales from your own town, or fewer and from further away.
- What's at stake is the yearly tax difference between your assessment and the corrected one (market value, or market value × average ratio in Chapter 123 towns), at your town's last tax rate, shown as a range. A county board judgment can also carry over to the next two tax years under the Freeze Act, unless the town revalues or reassesses.
How accurate is it?
We back-tested the value estimate on 22,440 real New Jersey sales: for each, we estimated the home's value from other sales exactly as the check does, then compared it with what it actually sold for.
- Typical miss: about 12% of the sale price.
- Within 10%: 43% of homes. Within 20%: 71%.
- No lean either way: the median error was +0.3%, so the estimate doesn't push values down to sell kits.
That's why results show a savings range and plain signals, not a single figure, and why a recent appraisal or purchase price, when you have one, is stronger evidence than our estimate.
Your own result also shows a likelihood (for example, "homes with numbers like yours were over the line about 8 times in 10").
Limitations
Estimates, not appraisals. Condition, renovations and anything the records don't show aren't in the numbers; a recent appraisal or purchase price is stronger evidence. The county board decides every appeal on the evidence presented.
Questions
Why not just compare my assessment with my neighbors'?
In New Jersey that isn't evidence. The board looks at your home's market value (and, in Chapter 123 towns, your town's common level range), so we estimate market value from sales.
Can the estimate be wrong?
Yes. Any estimate from sales can be. In our back-test about 43% of estimates were within 10% of the actual sale price and 71% within 20%. That's why the result shows a likelihood and a range, not a single promise.
Do you use my purchase price or appraisal?
If you enter a purchase or appraisal from 2024 or later, the check uses it as evidence of your home's own value, which is stronger than other homes' sales.
Why do you ask for my postcard assessment?
The state's latest public tax list is a few years old, and many towns (most of Monmouth County) reassess every year, so the number on your current postcard is the one that matters. Without it, the check uses the older figure and says so.
How often do you update?
When the state publishes new Chapter 123 ratios, when new sales files come out, and before each appeal season, when we also re-check which towns are assessed at market value.
Sources
- NJ Division of Taxation, 2027 Chapter 123 common level ranges (average ratio, lower and upper limits by municipality). Ratios above 100% count as 100%, and upper limits are capped at 100%.
- NJ Division of Taxation, SR1A sales file (usable sales, April 2025 – October 2026) and the MOD-IV tax list.
- N.J.S.A. 54:51A-6 (Chapter 123) and 54:3-22(f): Chapter 123 doesn't apply in a year a town revalues or reassesses; Monmouth County Board of Taxation appeal handbook (towns that reassess every year); Burlington and Gloucester county reassessment notices for 2027.
- NJ appeal calendar: January 15 in Burlington, Gloucester and Monmouth (alternate calendar); April 1 elsewhere, May 1 in towns with a revaluation or reassessment that year.
- County boards of taxation: filing instructions and fees (re-checked every season).
Last updated November 21, 2026. Data: NJ Division of Taxation (Chapter 123 ratios, SR1A sales, MOD-IV tax list).
