ENES

Unequal appraisal: the Texas protest argument most homeowners don't use

Updated November 21, 2026 · Applies to the 2027 protest season

Texas gives homeowners two ways to argue a value down. The first, market value, says your home wouldn't sell for the appraised amount. The second, unequal appraisal, says your home is valued higher than comparable homes once they're adjusted to match yours. You can win on the second even if your value is at or below what the house would sell for.

Why it matters in Texas

Texas is a non-disclosure state: sale prices aren't public record. That makes the market-value argument hard for homeowners, who rarely have access to sale prices. Appraised values of every home, however, are public. Unequal appraisal uses exactly that data.

What the law says

Under Tax Code §41.43(b)(3), the appraisal review board has to decide an unequal-appraisal protest in your favor unless the district shows your value is no higher than the median value of a reasonable number of comparable properties, appropriately adjusted. The same standard applies in district court under §42.26(a)(3).

How to build the evidence

  1. Pick comparable homes: same HCAD neighborhood, same quality grade, similar size and similar age.
  2. Adjust each to your home. The simplest method: take each comparable's building value per square foot, multiply by your square footage, and add your own land value.
  3. Take the median. Not the lowest comparable; the median of a reasonable number of them, not a hand-picked few.
  4. Compare. If the median adjusted value is below your appraised value, that's your ask.

How often it's there

After the 2026 protest season, our check found that about 22% of Harris County homes were still valued at least 5% (and $7,500) above the median of their adjusted comparables. Most of those owners (74%) didn't protest in 2026.

Limits

Adjustments matter. A board will discount comparables that are much bigger, newer or on a busy road, and HCAD will bring its own set. Present a clean table, explain your adjustments, and be ready to discuss theirs.

Frequently asked questions

Can I win an unequal appraisal protest if my value is below market?

Yes. The test compares your value with the median of comparable homes adjusted to yours, not with what your home would sell for.

How many comparable homes do I need?

The law says a reasonable number. Five is a practical minimum; ten to twenty-five is stronger.

Where do I find comparable homes' values?

HCAD's property search and public data show every home's appraised value, size, age and quality grade.

Related guides

Sources

General information, not legal or tax advice. Rules and procedures can change; check your notice and HCAD for your exact dates.

Last updated November 21, 2026. Data: HCAD public data: 2026 appraisal roll (notice and certified values) and 2026 protest hearing records. How we calculate this.