How the Texas check works
Texas sale prices aren't public, so our check uses the argument the Tax Code allows on public data: unequal appraisal (Tax Code §41.43(b)(3)).
Data
Each appraisal district's own public data. We cover single-family homes and refresh when a district publishes new values; until 2027 notices are out, checks use 2026 values.
- Harris County: HCAD public data: 2026 appraisal roll (notice and certified values) and 2026 protest hearing records.
- Travis County: TCAD's 2026 certified appraisal export (July 2026).
- Tarrant County: TAD's 2026 appraisal export (November 2026) and TAD's 2026 residential comparable-attribute data, including TAD's own equity indicated values.
- Collin County: Collin CAD's 2026 appraisal data on the Texas Open Data Portal (notice, prior-year and certified values, protest flags).
- Dallas County: DCAD's 2026 certified data files with supplemental changes (October 2026), including 2025 market values.
- Fort Bend County: FBCAD's 2026 property data export (October 2026) and residential segment file.
Comparable homes
Homes the district itself treats as similar: the same neighborhood and quality grade, comparable in size and age. Where a neighborhood has too few, we look a little wider, always within the same district. We use a reasonable number of comparables, as the Tax Code requires, never a hand-picked few.
Indicated value
Each comparable is adjusted to the checked home (for size, and keeping the home's own land and features), and we take the median of the adjusted values, the standard in §41.43(b)(3). The gap is your value minus that median.
Verdicts
- Strong case: value at least 5% and $7,500 above the indicated value.
- Good case: at least 2% above.
- Standard case: in line with similar homes. In 2026 about 8 in 10 owners who protested still got a reduction, so we don't tell anyone not to protest.
- Not enough similar homes: fewer than 5 comparables.
How accurate is it?
We scored every Harris County home on its 2026 notice value, then looked at what actually happened to the 80,716 owners who protested on their own (HCAD hearing records).
| Our rating | Owner protests | Got a reduction | Typical cut when they did |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strong case | 20,009 | 83% | 6.7% |
| Good case | 11,252 | 84% | 6.1% |
| Standard case | 48,681 | 79% | 5.9% |
What this means: in Texas most owners who protest get something, about 80% here, so we never tell anyone not to protest. Homes we rated strong or good got a reduction more often than standard ones (83–84% vs 79%), and strong cases got the bigger cuts (6.7% vs 5.9%). The difference is real but modest. The rating is a guide, not a promise; the kit's value is the evidence and the steps.
Savings
Estimated savings are the reduction in taxable value times an assumed 2.2% total tax rate, shown as a typical range. If a homestead cap applies, only the part of a reduction below the capped value counts this year.
Back-test
Harris County is the one district that publishes protest outcomes, so that's where we test. We compared our verdicts on April 2026 notice values with what HCAD and the ARB actually granted in 2026. Owners with a strong case won about 83% of the time versus 79% for a standard case; the size of the gap tracked the size of the cut. That's why verdicts rank the strength of your evidence rather than predict a yes/no.
Limits
Public records don't show condition, renovations or location details like a busy road. The appraisal district and the ARB decide. Everything here is an estimate, not an appraisal or legal advice.
Last updated November 21, 2026. Data: HCAD public data: 2026 appraisal roll (notice and certified values) and 2026 protest hearing records. How we calculate this.
